
TL;DR - Key Takeaways
- Oregon's general rule is that a company isn't liable for the negligence of an independent contractor it hires. That rule protects a carrier only if the driver was an independent contractor.
- For vicarious liability, Oregon courts ask whether the company had the right to control the manner and means of the driver's work. A contract that calls the driver an independent contractor is evidence of status, but it isn't conclusive.
- The Oregon Court of Appeals, in Brown v. Pettinari, 165 Or App 279 (2000), reversed summary judgment on the vicarious liability claim against a hauling company whose contract recited that its owner-operator was an independent contractor.
- 49 CFR 390.5T defines "employee" to include an independent contractor who is operating a commercial motor vehicle. That definition governs federal safety compliance, and Oregon law governs vicarious liability.
- The lease, the contractor agreement, dispatch records and electronic logging data are evidence of whether the carrier had the right to control the driving.
- A negligent driver is personally liable whether employee or contractor.
- Most Oregon personal injury lawsuits must be filed within two years (ORS 12.110).

After a tractor-trailer crash on I-84 or I-5 in Portland, the trucking company's insurer may tell the injured person that the driver was an owner-operator and that the company isn't responsible. Under Oregon law, that position doesn't end the claim against the company. The driver's status is a question of fact when the evidence of control conflicts.
I'm Mike Chaloupka, managing partner at Metier Law Firm, licensed in Oregon and the holder of a Class A commercial driver's license. "The contract records what the carrier and the driver called their arrangement," I tell clients. "In Oregon, the legal question is who had the right to direct how the truck was driven, and we look for that evidence in the carrier's own records."
The Independent Contractor Rule in Oregon
The independent contractor defense has a basis in Oregon law. The Oregon Court of Appeals stated the general rule in Soderback v. Townsend, 57 Or App 366, 644 P2d 640 (1982): a business that hires an independent contractor isn't liable for that contractor's negligence. The court noted that the rule has exceptions.
Vicarious liability makes a company responsible for the negligence of an employee acting within the scope of employment. Unless an exception applies, it requires an employment relationship. Carriers raise the independent contractor argument for that reason, and it is one of the common defenses used by trucking companies.

The Portland Truck Accident Independent Contractor Driver Defense and Oregon's Control Test
Soderback requires more than control over the result of the work. To be vicariously liable, the company must also have had the right to control the manner and means of doing it. The court added: "The right to exercise control is decisive."
Setting a delivery deadline controls the result. A carrier that assigns the route, sets the driving hours and requires its own dispatch system gives a jury evidence of a right to control the manner and means. Soderback directs courts to examine the employment arrangement itself, and the contract's description of the driver is one fact in that examination.
How the Oregon Court of Appeals Applied the Test to an Owner-Operator Lease
In Brown v. Pettinari, 165 Or App 279, 994 P2d 1231 (2000), a company that hauled mobile homes leased a truck from an owner-operator. Their contract recited that he was an independent contractor and not an employee. On the return trip from a delivery, his pilot-car driver crossed into the oncoming lane and struck another car. The trial court granted the hauling company summary judgment. The Court of Appeals reversed on the vicarious liability claim and described the evidence of the owner-operator's status as mixed.
The lease gave the company "exclusive possession, control and use" of the truck, and it required the owner-operator to devote the truck to the company's exclusive service. According to the court, this language made the relationship ambiguous, which left the question for trial.
On remand, a jury could find that the owner-operator was the company's employee and that his pilot-car driver, as his employee, was also the company's employee. A Portland truck accident independent contractor driver defense therefore doesn't guarantee the carrier summary judgment. The signed contract, even one that favors the carrier, doesn't decide the driver's status.

Federal Trucking Rules and Oregon Liability
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations define "employee" in 49 CFR 390.5T. The term includes "an independent contractor while in the course of operating a commercial motor vehicle." As a result, the carrier must comply with the driver qualification rules (Part 391), the hours-of-service rules (Part 395) and the inspection rules (Part 396) for an owner-operator. Section 390.5T defines the term for the safety regulations and doesn't state a rule of tort liability.
A separate rule, 49 CFR 376.12(c)(1), requires an equipment lease to give the carrier "exclusive possession, control, and use of the equipment for the duration of the lease." Paragraph (c)(4) of the same rule says that requirement isn't intended to affect whether the driver is an independent contractor or an employee. In Brown, the Court of Appeals treated the driver's status as a question of state law and used the lease's exclusive-possession clause as evidence on that question. The lease terms are evidence of control in an Oregon case. Neither the lease nor the federal rules establishes the driver's status as a matter of law for either party.
If you or a loved one was injured in a crash with a commercial truck, call us at 866-377-3800 or schedule a free consultation at www.metierlaw.com.
The Records We Request on the Driver's Status
We start by sending the carrier a preservation demand, which we explain in our post on spoliation letters. After a lawsuit is filed, we request these records in discovery:
- The equipment lease, every addendum and the independent contractor agreement
- Dispatch records, load assignments and in-cab messages
- Electronic logging device and telematics data
- Records of who set the routes, delivery windows and driving hours
- Payment records for fuel, insurance and maintenance
- Records of whether the driver hauled for any other carrier
Our article on how a Portland truck accident lawsuit works covers the discovery stage and venue. A lawsuit over a crash on I-205 or US 30 inside Multnomah County can be filed in Multnomah County Circuit Court.
Crashes on the Return Trip After a Delivery
A carrier may also argue that the driver was outside the scope of employment once the delivery was complete. The crash in Brown happened on the return trip, and the court addressed that argument through the special errand exception to Oregon's going-and-coming rule. Relying on the Oregon Supreme Court's decision in Krushwitz v. McDonald's Restaurants, 323 Or 520 (1996), the Court of Appeals said the exception applies if the employee was furthering the employer's business at the time of the injury or the employer had the right to control the employee's travel. Whether it applied was also a question of fact, the court held.

Claims the Driver's Status Doesn't Affect
The driver is personally liable for negligent driving regardless of status. A claim that the company was itself negligent, for example in hiring or training the driver, is a separate claim from vicarious liability. We explain that proof in how negligence is established in a Portland truck accident. Parcel van and box truck crashes are covered in our post on delivery and box truck crashes in Portland.
ORS 12.110 sets a two-year deadline for most Oregon personal injury lawsuits, and a dispute over the driver's status doesn't extend it. Our guide to the Oregon personal injury statute of limitations lists the exceptions.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does it matter that the driver signed an independent contractor agreement?
The agreement is evidence of the driver's status, but it isn't conclusive. The contract in Brown v. Pettinari recited that the owner-operator was an independent contractor, and the Oregon Court of Appeals still held that his status was a question of fact because other lease terms supported an inference of control.
Doesn't federal trucking law treat the driver as the company's employee?
For federal safety compliance, yes. Under 49 CFR 390.5T, "employee" includes an independent contractor operating a commercial motor vehicle. Oregon vicarious liability depends on the right to control the manner and means of the driving.
Does an owner-operator truck accident claim in Oregon end when the adjuster says the driver was a contractor?
No. The adjuster is stating the position of the carrier and its insurer, and that position isn't a legal ruling. A judge or jury applies Oregon's right-to-control test to the carrier's contract and records.
Our Response to a Carrier's Independent Contractor Defense
When the carrier's records and its contract conflict on who had the right to control the driving, Oregon law treats the driver's status as a question of fact for trial. Our Portland truck accident lawyers send a preservation demand before suit and compare the carrier's records with each term of the contract. We handle these claims statewide through our Oregon truck accident practice.
Call Metier Law Firm at 866-377-3800 or schedule your free consultation today at www.metierlaw.com.
Disclaimer: Past results discussed should not be considered a guarantee of your results as the factors of every case are individually unique. This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified attorney from Metier Law Firm regarding your individual situation for legal advice.
Tell Us About Your Case – Free Case Review with a Personal Injury Lawyer
(866) 377-3800Our Locations
.webp)
Do I have a Case?
How Much Should I Be Offered?
Do I Need an Attorney?
If these questions have crossed your mind, let us help. You may need a little direction or may not need an attorney at all, but you deserve to be confident knowing your options. We can provide you with information about our Attorneys of the West® accident investigations and legal services. Your confidential consultation with us is totally free.



