Motorcycle Accidents
Text Link
Motorcycle Accidents

Portland Motorcycle Accident Sudden Emergency Defense: How Oregon Law Treats "It Was an Emergency"

Portland motorcycle accident sudden emergency defense: how Oregon's 2008 ruling on the emergency jury instruction affects an injured rider's claim.
Table of Contents
Portland Motorcycle Accident Sudden Emergency Defense: How Oregon Law Treats "It Was an Emergency"
by
Patrick DiBenedetto
November 4, 2026

Key Takeaways

  • In Bjorndal v. Weitman, 344 Or 470, 184 P3d 1115 (2008), the Oregon Supreme Court held that the emergency jury instruction "should not be given" in ordinary vehicle negligence cases.
  • In those cases, a driver who says a sudden hazard forced a swerve is judged by the ordinary negligence standard, which is reasonable care.
  • Evidence that events happened suddenly is still allowed, and the driver's lawyer may argue it to the jury.
  • The jury may also consider evidence of the driver's speed, following distance and attention before the hazard appeared.
Portland motorcycle crash infographic comparing emergency instructions and evidence, illustrating the Bjorndal crash sequence, and explaining reasonable care, shared fault and the general two-year deadline.

A driver moves into your lane on a Portland street and hits you. The driver then tells the insurer that another vehicle pulled into the way and left no time to react. A Portland motorcycle accident sudden emergency defense rests on that claim. Under Bjorndal v. Weitman, 344 Or 470, 184 P3d 1115 (2008), an Oregon jury weighs it with the rest of the proof on reasonable care. At Metier Motorcycle Lawyers, Patrick DiBenedetto and our team gather evidence of how the driver was driving before the hazard appeared.

"When a driver testifies that there was no time to react, we look at what came before that. Speed and following distance help a jury decide whether the driver's own conduct played a part in the emergency," says Patrick DiBenedetto, Partner at Metier Law Firm.

What the Emergency Jury Instruction Said

Until 2008, an Oregon trial court could give the jury a separate emergency instruction in a vehicle case when a party asked for it. The version at issue in Bjorndal v. Weitman was Uniform Civil Jury Instruction (UCJI) 20.08. It read:

"People who are suddenly placed in a position of peril through no negligence of their own, and who are compelled to act without opportunity for reflection, are not negligent if they make a choice as a reasonably careful person placed in such a position might make, even though they do not make the wisest choice."

The Oregon Court of Appeals had questioned that kind of instruction in 1987. In Templeton v. Smith, 88 Or App 266, it wrote, "We doubt that an emergency charge should ever be given in an ordinary automobile accident case."

Motorcyclist in a full-face helmet riding on a Portland street with a car following behind.

The Portland Motorcycle Accident Sudden Emergency Defense After Bjorndal v. Weitman

What the Oregon Supreme Court Decided

Bjorndal began with a two-vehicle crash on Highway 22 in Linn County. The defendant was following the plaintiff's van and glanced away from the road ahead. When he looked back, the van was slowing. He braked and steered left to pass as the van turned left, and the vehicles collided.

At the defendant's request, the trial judge gave the emergency instruction, and the jury found him not negligent. The Court of Appeals affirmed.

On May 8, 2008, the Oregon Supreme Court reversed and sent the case back to the trial court. It held that the emergency instruction, "as used in ordinary vehicle negligence cases, is an inaccurate and confusing supplement to the instructions on the law of negligence and, therefore, should not be given."

The court explained that the instruction "misstates the law of negligence by introducing an inquiry respecting whether a person has made the 'wisest choice,' rather than focusing on whether the person used reasonable care, given all the circumstances."

The Instruction the Court Left in Place

The general negligence instruction, UCJI 20.02, was sufficient in the court's view. As quoted in the opinion, it begins, "The law requires every person to use reasonable care to avoid harming others." It then tells jurors to weigh the dangers that were apparent or reasonably foreseeable when the events occurred. That standard covers the swerve and the driving before it.

What the Driver May Argue

The ruling addressed the jury instruction only. The court wrote that parties may introduce evidence and argue about the emergency nature of the circumstances. A driver who hit a motorcyclist can testify that another vehicle moved into the lane or that debris fell from a truck. On that evidence, the jury can find that the driver used reasonable care.

In a footnote, the court wrote: "We confine our ruling to vehicle negligence cases because that is the context of this case." A negligence claim over a car hitting a motorcycle on a Portland street is a vehicle negligence case.

Windshield-mounted dashcam in a parked car, with a motorcycle visible outside on a Portland street.

Evidence of How the Driver Was Driving Before the Hazard

When a driver swerved and hit a motorcycle and then claims a sudden emergency, we collect evidence of how that person was driving beforehand:

  • Following distance. ORS 811.485 makes it a traffic violation to follow another vehicle "more closely than is reasonable and prudent." Following distance and speed together determine how much time a driver has to brake when the vehicle ahead slows.
  • Speed. Oregon's basic speed rule, ORS 811.100, prohibits driving faster than is "reasonable and prudent" given conditions that include traffic, the road surface, weather and visibility.
  • Attention. The Bjorndal defendant had looked away from the road just before he had to react. Phone records, obtained through discovery after suit is filed, can show whether the driver was using a phone. Statements to police and insurers can establish where the driver was looking.
  • Video and witnesses. Dash camera video, business security video and eyewitness accounts can show whether the hazard existed and how much time the driver had.

If the insurer argues that you share fault, ORS 31.600 controls. Your claim isn't barred unless your fault is greater than the combined fault of the other people the statute compares. Any damages are then reduced by your percentage of fault. Our post on Portland motorcycle accident comparative fault shows how those percentages work.

If you've been hurt in a motorcycle crash and need answers, call us at 833-4-MOTO-LAW (833-466-8652) or schedule a free consultation at www.metierlaw.com.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is sudden emergency a defense in Oregon car and motorcycle crashes?

Not as a separate jury instruction. Since Bjorndal v. Weitman, the emergency instruction should not be given in ordinary vehicle negligence cases. A Portland motorcycle accident sudden emergency defense is an argument that the driver used reasonable care.

The driver says another car cut them off and they had to swerve into me. Does that end my claim?

No. The driver may tell the jury about the other car, but the question remains whether the driver used reasonable care. The jury answers that question with evidence of speed, following distance and attention before the other car appeared.

Business security camera overlooking a Portland intersection, with a motorcycle parked near the curb.

Did Oregon eliminate the sudden emergency doctrine?

No. Bjorndal held only that the emergency jury instruction should not be given in ordinary vehicle negligence cases. Parties can still present proof and argument about an emergency.

What if the driver says a seizure or blackout caused the crash?

In Loper v. Brakel, 343 Or App 445 (2025), the Oregon Court of Appeals held that "sudden medical emergency is encompassed in a general denial, rather than being an affirmative defense to negligence." Under that decision, a driver can raise it without pleading it as a separate defense. The court treated the issue as one of foreseeability. It asked whether the driver had reason to believe the episode might occur. The Oregon Supreme Court allowed review of that decision on January 15, 2026, so the rule may change.

How long do I have to file a motorcycle injury lawsuit in Oregon?

ORS 12.110(1) requires an action for injury to the person to be commenced within two years. For a crash injury, we count that period from the date of the crash. We explain that deadline in more detail in our Oregon personal injury statute of limitations post.

How Metier Law Firm Responds to a Sudden Emergency Argument

In an Oregon vehicle negligence case, a claimed emergency is one fact the jury weighs on reasonable care. Once we're retained, our Portland motorcycle accident lawyers send preservation requests for video and phone records. We also interview witnesses. The Oregon motorcycle accident lawyers page covers how we handle claims across the state. Metier Law Firm reviews Portland motorcycle crash claims at no cost.

Call Metier Motorcycle Lawyers at 833-4-MOTO-LAW (833-466-8652) or schedule your free consultation today at www.metierlaw.com.

Disclaimer: Past results discussed should not be considered a guarantee of your results as the factors of every case are individually unique. This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified attorney from Metier Law Firm regarding your individual situation for legal advice.

Our Locations

Personal Injury lawyer Metier Law Firm
FREE CONSULTATION

Do I have a Case?

How Much Should I Be Offered?

Do I Need an Attorney?

If these questions have crossed your mind, let us help. You may need a little direction or may not need an attorney at all, but you deserve to be confident knowing your options.  We can provide you with information about our Attorneys of the West® accident investigations and legal services. Your confidential consultation with us is totally free.

Keep up with us!

We care about the protection of your data. Read our Privacy Policy.