Our StaffShelli Lilly

Shelli Lilly

Records Administrator

Shelli was born in South Dakota but later moved to Fort Collins with her parents and five siblings. After graduating from Rocky Mountain High School, she attended Front Range Community College then entered the work force. Just before joining the firm in 2013, she worked as a medical assistant for a local spine surgeon. Shelli’s kind and fun loving personality is most evident when spending time with her 10 nieces and nephews. In her spare time, Shelli enjoys hiking, attending concerts, spending time with family and camping.

$415M
Won in Settlements and Verdicts
99%
Case Wins
40+
Years of Experience
*4.8
Google Reviews

Top reasons to Choose The Colorado Personal Injury Lawyers at Metier Law Firm

Goliath’s might with David’s size

Financial advantages of a large firm with the close, personal client relationship of a small firm

We’re the lawyers other lawyers hire

Attorneys across the country seek out and trust our firm to help their clients

We get results

From record-setting $50 million verdicts to $50,000 policy limit settlements, every penny that can be won, will be won

100% Personal Injury

We don’t practice any other law and dedicate our time entirely to helping personal injury victims

Now, Meet Our Lead Attorney

Patrick DiBenedetto

Lead Attorney, Metier Motorcycle Lawyers

For over twenty years, Patrick DiBenedetto has focused his legal practice exclusively on motorcycle accident cases. This singular focus has given him a depth of knowledge that few attorneys in the country can match, having represented more than 1,500 riders and their families after serious crashes.

Patrick's commitment to excellence extends beyond his own casework. He has both attended and taught at the renowned Trial Lawyers College in Wyoming, a program dedicated to helping attorneys become more effective, persuasive, and compassionate advocates in the courtroom.

"He doesn't just represent riders. He is one."

An avid motorcyclist himself, Patrick has logged numerous thousand mile days in the saddle, giving him firsthand insight into the freedom, risks, and unique challenges that come with life on two wheels. This isn't a lawyer who learned about motorcycles from a textbook. He understands the mindset of a rider because he lives it.

That combination, decades of specialized courtroom experience paired with genuine passion for riding, is what makes Patrick exceptional in this role. When a client sits down with him, they aren't just getting an attorney. They're getting an advocate who understands their world from both sides of the table.

✓ 1,500+ Motorcycle Cases

Handled exclusively, start to finish

✓ 20+ Years, Motorcycle Law Only

No other practice areas, ever

✓ Trial Lawyers College, Wyoming

Attended and taught trial advocacy

Our Promise To You

We Don't Farm Out Cases.

When you choose Metier Motorcycle Lawyers, you know exactly who you'll be working with, Patrick and his team.

Your First Call

You'll talk to the same team from day one, not a call center that hands your case off to a stranger.

Every Step In Between

Patrick and his team handle the investigation, the negotiations, and the courtroom work themselves, so nothing gets lost in a handoff.

Until You Receive Your Check

The same faces you met at the start are the ones who see your case through to the finish.

A team dedicated to helping you get back on your feet, and back in the saddle.

Rider Safety

Follow These Steps After A Motorcycle Accident

The minutes after a crash are disorienting. This order of operations, from Metier Motorcycle Lawyers, is built to protect your health first and your claim second, because both matter.

  1. Prioritize Safety First - If you're able to move, get yourself and your motorcycle out of the flow of traffic. Turn on hazard lights or use flares and warning triangles if available. Your safety and the safety of others on the road comes first.
  2. Call 911 Immediately - Even if injuries seem minor, request police and medical response. Motorcycle injuries are often more serious than they initially appear, and a police report creates an official record that will be essential for any insurance claim or legal case.
  3. Seek Medical Attention, Even If You Feel Fine - Adrenaline can mask pain and injury symptoms for hours or even days. Get evaluated by a medical professional as soon as possible. This protects your health and creates a documented medical record connecting your injuries to the accident.
  4. Document Everything - If you're physically able:
    1. Take photos of your motorcycle, the other vehicle or vehicles, road conditions, skid marks, and any visible injuries
    2. Photograph the accident scene from multiple angles
    3. Note weather conditions, traffic signals, and road hazards
    4. Get contact and insurance information from all drivers involved
    5. Get names and phone numbers of any witnesses, since their statements can be critical if fault is disputed later
    6. Keep medical bills, repair estimates, lost wage documentation, and any correspondence related to the accident going forward
  5. Avoid Admitting Fault - Stick to the facts when speaking with police and other drivers. Don't apologize or speculate about who caused the accident. Determining fault is often more complex than it first appears, especially with motorcycle accidents.
  6. Call Metier Motorcycle Lawyers Before You Call Any Insurance Company - Before you give a recorded statement to your insurer or the other driver's insurance company, talk to an attorney at Metier Motorcycle Lawyers. Insurance adjusters may try to minimize your claim, and motorcycle accident cases carry unique challenges, from rider bias among juries and insurers to the severity of injuries involved. We'll make sure your rights are protected before you say anything that could affect your claim.

Videos

How Washington's Pure Comparative-Fault Rule Affects Your Seattle Truck Accident Claim
How Washington's Pure Comparative-Fault Rule Affects Your Seattle Truck Accident Claim
Washington is a pure comparative-fault state. A Seattle truck accident lawyer explains how partial fault affects your claim. Call 866-377-3800.
by
August 6, 2026
The Motorcycle Crash Risk Factors You Can Actually Control: What a Federal Safety Study Means for Fort Collins Riders
The Motorcycle Crash Risk Factors You Can Actually Control: What a Federal Safety Study Means for Fort Collins Riders
A Fort Collins motorcycle accident lawyer explains the crash risk factors you control and how Colorado's 50% fault bar affects your injury claim.
by
August 5, 2026
Who's Liable When a Delivery or Box Truck Crashes in Portland? Last-Mile Freight and Local-Carrier Responsibility
Who's Liable When a Delivery or Box Truck Crashes in Portland? Last-Mile Freight and Local-Carrier Responsibility
Who pays when a delivery or box truck crashes in Portland? A Portland truck accident lawyer explains driver, contractor, and brand liability.
by
August 4, 2026
The Most Common Motorcycle Accident Injuries and Why They Shape Your Cheyenne Injury Claim
The Most Common Motorcycle Accident Injuries and Why They Shape Your Cheyenne Injury Claim
The most common Cheyenne motorcycle accident injuries and how severity plus medical documentation shape what your Wyoming injury claim is worth.
by
August 3, 2026
2026 Sturgis Motorcycle Rally Tips: Sturgis Salutes America
2026 Sturgis Motorcycle Rally Tips: Sturgis Salutes America
2026 Sturgis Motorcycle Rally tips for Colorado and Wyoming riders: safety, packing, camping, Black Hills rides, and staying safe on the road there.
by
July 31, 2026
What Is a Wrongful Death Lawsuit in Denver?
What Is a Wrongful Death Lawsuit in Denver?
A Denver wrongful death lawyer explains who can file, what to prove, damages, and deadlines after a fatal truck or motorcycle crash.
by
July 30, 2026

Awards and Recognition

ATAA Board Certified Truck Accident Law badgeRated by Super Lawyers - T. Thomas MetierNBTA certificationsMillion Dollar Advocates ForumTop 1% Trial CounselNation's Premier NAOPIA top Ten Attorney 2014Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent 2021 Peer Rated for Highest Level of Professional ExcellenceMartindale-Hubbell Client Champion Silver 2021Best Lawyers recognition badge for Thomas MetierAAJ Leaders Forum Advocate 2022 badgeNational Association of Distinguished Counsel Top One Percent badgeAmerican Association for Justice Presidents Club badge
Personal Injury lawyer Metier Law Firm
FREE CONSULTATION

Do I have a Case?

How Much Should I Be Offered?

Do I Need an Attorney?

If these questions have crossed your mind, let us help. You may need a little direction or may not need an attorney at all, but you deserve to be confident knowing your options.  We can provide you with information about our Attorneys of the West® accident investigations and legal services. Your confidential consultation with us is totally free.

Keep up with us!

We care about the protection of your data. Read our Privacy Policy.