Why Maintenance Records Matter in Truck Accident Claims

Key Takeaways:

• Federal law requires trucking companies to maintain detailed inspection and repair records for at least one year, and violations of these FMCSA regulations can prove negligence in your case
• Common truck maintenance violations include brake failures, tire defects, faulty lighting, and suspension problems that directly cause serious crashes
• Trucking companies often destroy, alter, or "lose" maintenance records after accidents, making it critical to hire a truck accident lawyer immediately to preserve evidence
• Maintenance records prove what the company knew about mechanical problems before your crash and establish patterns of neglect that strengthen your claim
• A truck accident lawyer can compel disclosure of maintenance logs, inspection reports, and electronic data that companies won't voluntarily provide

A semi slams into stopped traffic because its brakes failed. A tractor-trailer's tire blows out, sending the rig across the centerline. An 18-wheeler's lights malfunction at night, making it nearly invisible until it's too late. These crashes happen more often than they should, and when we dig into the details as a truck accident lawyer, we find the same problem over and over again: someone didn't maintain that truck the way federal law requires.

If you've been hurt in a crash involving a commercial truck, those truck maintenance records could be the strongest evidence in your case. They show whether the trucking company followed the rules or gambled with your safety to save a few dollars.

‍

What Federal Law Says About Truck Maintenance

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration doesn't leave truck maintenance up to chance. Under 49 CFR 396.3, trucking companies must inspect their vehicles regularly, fix defects promptly, and keep detailed records of every repair and inspection for at least a year. These aren't suggestions. They're legal requirements, and when companies ignore them, people get seriously injured or killed.

We've seen it time and again. A driver reports a brake problem three weeks before a crash, but the company puts off the repair. An inspection catches worn tires, but nobody replaces them. A mechanic warns about a failing suspension system, and management decides to "monitor it" instead of fixing it. Those decisions show up in the maintenance logs, and that's exactly what makes truck maintenance records so valuable when building your claim.

Common Violations We Find in Maintenance Records

When we obtain commercial vehicle maintenance records in truck accident cases, certain FMCSA regulations violations appear repeatedly:

Brake System Problems

According to FMCSA inspection data, brake-related violations show up in nearly 30% of roadside inspections. Worn pads, leaking air lines, failing ABS systems—these aren't minor issues. When brakes fail on an 80,000-pound truck, the results are catastrophic. The records often show the company knew about brake problems for weeks or months before the crash.

Tire Defects and Failures

Bald treads, improper inflation, sidewall damage that should have taken a tire out of service—tire problems cause blowouts that lead to rollovers and multi-vehicle pileups. Federal regulations require specific tread depths and regular tire inspections, but companies skip these checks or ignore what they find.

Lighting and Electrical Issues

Broken headlights, malfunctioning turn signals, and faulty brake lights make trucks nearly impossible to see in the dark or bad weather. These are simple fixes, but they cost money and downtime. Some companies would rather risk it.

Suspension and Steering Failures

Worn shocks, broken springs, loose steering components—these problems affect how a truck handles, especially in emergency situations. When truck maintenance violations involve suspension or steering, crashes become almost inevitable.

If you or a loved one was injured in a crash with a commercial truck, call us at 866-377-3800 or schedule a free consultation at www.metierlaw.com.

How a Truck Accident Lawyer Obtains These Records

Trucking companies don't hand over maintenance records willingly. They know what those documents reveal. That's why you need a truck accident lawyer who understands how to compel disclosure and what to look for once we get them.

We start by sending a spoliation letter immediately after the crash. This legal notice requires the company to preserve all evidence, including maintenance logs, inspection reports, repair orders, and electronic data. Without this step, critical evidence disappears.

Then we use legal discovery tools to obtain:

• Company maintenance logs showing all scheduled and unscheduled repairs
• Pre-trip and post-trip inspection reports completed by drivers
• State and federal inspection records from DOT roadside checks
• Repair shop invoices that detail what was fixed and when
• Electronic logging device data that may include diagnostic codes and mechanical alerts

Companies often claim records are lost, incomplete, or protected. We push back hard when that happens, and courts take destruction of evidence seriously.

What These Records Prove in Court

Truck maintenance records serve specific legal purposes that strengthen your claim. They establish that the trucking company owed you a duty of care under federal law. They show the company knew or should have known about dangerous defects. They prove those defects caused or contributed to your crash.

When we find repeated warnings about the same problem, that shows a pattern of trucking company negligence. When we find falsified inspection reports, that can support punitive damages. When we find missing records for required inspections, that proves regulatory violations.

Insurance companies try to shift blame to other factors—weather, road conditions, even you. Solid truck accident evidence from maintenance records cuts through those arguments. The data doesn't lie.

Time Matters More Than You Think

Here's something most people don't realize: maintenance records can be altered, lost, or destroyed after a crash. The longer you wait to contact a truck accident lawyer, the harder it becomes to secure this truck accident evidence.

We've handled cases where companies "accidentally" disposed of maintenance files before we could subpoena them. We've seen inspection reports that were clearly modified after the crash. We've dealt with repair shops that suddenly can't find invoices from the week before the accident.

That's why we move fast. The day you hire us, we're sending preservation letters and filing motions if necessary to protect evidence. We're contacting the repair shops before anyone else does. We're downloading electronic data before it gets wiped.

Frequently Asked Questions

What if the trucking company says they lost the maintenance records?

Federal law requires trucking companies to maintain these records for at least one year. If they "lost" records relevant to your crash, that's spoliation of evidence. Courts can impose sanctions, including allowing the jury to assume those records would have shown negligence. A truck accident lawyer can file a spoliation motion to address this.

How long do I have to file a truck accident claim?

Statutes of limitations vary by state. In Colorado, you generally have three years for personal injury claims, but other states have shorter deadlines. More importantly, evidence preservation needs to happen immediately after the crash, well before any filing deadline. Don't wait to contact an attorney.

Can I get these records myself without a lawyer?

Technically yes, but trucking companies rarely cooperate with individual requests. They know you don't have subpoena power or understanding of what records exist. They'll stall, provide incomplete documents, or claim privilege. Without a truck accident lawyer, you'll likely get nowhere.

What if the driver claims the truck was fine before the crash?

Driver statements mean nothing compared to documented truck maintenance records and truck maintenance violations. Drivers work for the company and may not even know about mechanical problems. The maintenance logs, inspection reports, and repair orders show the truth.

Do electronic logging devices track maintenance issues?

Many modern ELDs record diagnostic trouble codes, engine performance data, and system warnings. This electronic data can corroborate or contradict paper maintenance records. We know how to obtain and analyze this data as part of building your case.

We Know Trucking Because We've Been There

I hold a Commercial Driver's License. I've been behind the wheel of big rigs. I know what it takes to operate these vehicles safely, and I know what happens when companies cut corners on maintenance.

At Metier Law Firm, we don't just request records and hope for the best. We work with mechanical experts who interpret maintenance data. We analyze FMCSA regulations to identify every violation. We build cases that show exactly how a company's negligence caused your injuries.

When insurance companies try to lowball settlements or blame you for the crash, we use truck maintenance records to prove them wrong. When defense attorneys claim their client followed all the rules, we show the jury the documentary evidence of failure.

You shouldn't have to pay for a trucking company's decision to skip brake repairs or ignore tire problems. Let us uncover the truth in those maintenance files and fight for the compensation you deserve.

Call Metier Law Firm at 866-377-3800 or schedule your free consultation today at www.metierlaw.com.

‍

Disclaimer: Past results discussed should not be considered a guarantee of your results as the factors of every case are individually unique. This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified attorney from Metier Law Firm regarding your individual situation for legal advice.

‍